Shipwreck

[PK Toolboxxx]

ok for the people who have played it, i want everyones opinion on it. personally i think its great, and because it is a little larger i think it will work pretty well in reach.

[Valentine84]

I liked it alot too. Has the Midship "feel" but allows for Reach's gameplay much better

[Sabrea]

Yeah it reminds me of Midship/Heretic it is almost the same I am really excited to play a real game in it maybe set up some 4s tonight?

[PK Toolboxxx]

Yeah it reminds me of Midship/Heretic it is almost the same I am really excited to play a real game in it maybe set up some 4s tonight?

yeah sure. i played it last night with justin,, hooligan, maszik, plastic, gweedo, gym, and impended. first real fun game of reach in a while.

[Dibs]

It plays like midship but a little bit slower. it is big and teamshot is huge i for it.

[PK Toolboxxx]

It plays like midship but a little bit slower. it is big and teamshot is huge i for it.

i think its slower in just that movement without sprint in reach feels slower. but it is def. the fastest paced map in reach and i am a fan.

[Sabrea]

yeah sure. i played it last night with justin,, hooligan, maszik, plastic, gweedo, gym, and impended. first real fun game of reach in a while.

Ha yeah thats cool if we can get some people to run I am down to play!

[PK Toolboxxx]

sweet ill let u know.

[Dibs]

Yea. I feel like reach is a slower game then h3 and h2. The maps are alot bigger in reach too. I think that with some work on this map it could make it to the circuit. It plays well enough

[SecretSchnitzel]

The bulk of the MLG Forums community, to include Ponytar and a good number of Pros, do not like it. The only reason why it is in currently is because its the best of possibly two or three remakes. This is the reason why KC asked for a Midship remake for this week's map submission. This shipwreck of a map is not staying in the running for V3 after the week's end.

[PK Toolboxxx]

The bulk of the MLG Forums community, to include Ponytar and a good number of Pros, do not like it. The only reason why it is in currently is because its the best of possibly two or three remakes. This is the reason why KC asked for a Midship remake for this week's map submission. This shipwreck of a map is not staying in the running for V3 after the week's end.
really. y. its the best map reach had to offer thus far.

[Justin21]

Its the most fun ive had playing reach....just saying

[Benjak]

Bets Map I have played yet! I like it a lot! Hope it makes it as one of the new MLG maps!

[EGOisSICK]

Personally i am done with the feel of heretic plus it is a sloppy map...

[PK Toolboxxx]

Personally i am done with the feel of heretic plus it is a sloppy map...

explain the sloppy part. i am interested as to what u mean lol.

[Inexist]

explain the sloppy part. i am interested as to what u mean lol.

What he said.

[Dibs]

http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/FileDetails.aspx?fid=10798394&player=Ninja%20Shizoku
Incase someone wants to download it :)

[Jewjitsu]

i think it's good, but KC obviously wants an even better one, or at least a more accurate remake. in a couple of days, if people are actually working on them, we should hopefully see some really really good midships come out. i don't see what's wrong with it, except the fact that pink 3 should be a tad higher, but whatev.

[Imp3nded]

I think it's a good map. Sitting P3 and raining fire everywhere on the map was nostalgic, but I still don't think it's the best map in the game... I think that's a little over the edge. Countdown and Sanctuary still are the top two (imo).

[PK Toolboxxx]

I think it's a good map. Sitting P3 and raining fire everywhere on the map was nostalgic, but I still don't think it's the best map in the game... I think that's a little over the edge. Countdown and Sanctuary still are the top two (imo).
yeah i agree with the nostalgic thing. but the thing i think is best is its simple. countdown is a decent map but i think sanc is way over played and doesnt work perfect with reach. (imo aswell)

[Imp3nded]

Well you're talking to someone that doesn't think Countdown or Sanctuary are only decent maps. I think they're the best two maps since Halo 2 besides Narrows.

[PK Toolboxxx]

Well you're talking to someone that doesn't think Countdown or Sanctuary are only decent maps. I think they're the best two maps since Halo 2 besides Narrows.

lol true. but we disagree on maps alot. im not a huge fan of narrows.

[Justin21]

Pit is the greatest (imo)

[PK Toolboxxx]

huge fan of construct and onslot.

[RagingChickens]

All Halo 3 maps were incredible. Period. No more discussion! haha

But I do like Shipwreck. But for some reason I haven't heard anything about MLG even testing it or looking at it. Is there a reason? Because I need a Midship/Heretic in this game.....

[PlasTlC]

I liked it. Might just have been the group that played but it was very fun and i would vote for it every time in playlist. Car 3 is huge though, that was weird.

[SecretSchnitzel]

Seriously, this map is rubbish. Real Feedback Here. (http://forums.majorleaguegaming.com/topic/197737-shipwreck-miship-inspired-mlg-arena-map-submission/) Oh, and Enable and Diesle on Midship and the remake their waiting for on Enable's stream. (http://www.livestream.com/enable_/video?clipId=pla_e3dbf6c5-ed0c-460b-9562-675196698ecc)
The map is cramped, sloppily forged, and the proportions to the original are off. As far as remakes go, if you actually like this map your parents must have dropped you on your head as child... This has been one of the worst forged and most unenjoyable maps I've played to date (not including most ForgeHub maps). This map has actually hurt my love for the original. Yes, it really is that bad.

[PK Toolboxxx]

Seriously, this map is rubbish. Real Feedback Here. (http://forums.majorleaguegaming.com/topic/197737-shipwreck-miship-inspired-mlg-arena-map-submission/) Oh, and Enable and Diesle on Midship and the remake their waiting for on Enable's stream. (http://www.livestream.com/enable_/video?clipId=pla_e3dbf6c5-ed0c-460b-9562-675196698ecc)
The map is cramped, sloppily forged, and the proportions to the original are off. As far as remakes go, if you actually like this map your parents must have dropped you on your head as child... This has been one of the worst forged and most unenjoyable maps I've played to date (not including most ForgeHub maps). This map has actually hurt my love for the original. Yes, it really is that bad.

cool story bro. if you dont like the map thats all u got to say. but tell me why it is sloppy. i want to know. and im happy its not an exact remake. that wouldnt be fun with how reach plays.

[Bleuprint]

It doesn't play better for reach, its small and cramped. It looks sloppy because the large amount of curved walls. It's not that it was forged sloppy, it just looks bad. I agree with Schnitz.

Your "Cool story bro" is outdated by like 5 yrs so I suggest getting past it.

[SecretSchnitzel]

Poorly coordinated curvature, excessive object merging, tight door ways, corners that players get caught on, and non-flowing aesthetics. Throw in that the proportions are off, the rocks suck, frames get dropped, mediocre lines of sight and a sandy floor, you have yourselves a horribly Midship "remake". To sum it all up, the map is sloppy.
Now please tell, what makes it such an amazing map that you and your mates here feel the need to praise it as one of the best in Reach?

[Justin21]

Were not saying its the greatest, only that its fun to play compared to what mlg has already, dont get so offensive when someone is giving their opinion, you might know more about forge and such but it doesnt mean that someones opinion is trying to insult your intelligence

[chris_cr33p]

i like it too. the size is just right

[PK Toolboxxx]

Poorly coordinated curvature, excessive object merging, tight door ways, corners that players get caught on, and non-flowing aesthetics. Throw in that the proportions are off, the rocks suck, frames get dropped, mediocre lines of sight and a sandy floor, you have yourselves a horribly Midship "remake". To sum it all up, the map is sloppy.
Now please tell, what makes it such an amazing map that you and your mates here feel the need to praise it as one of the best in Reach?

we like it because its better than the shit we have. thank you for your the reasons on y it sucks. please if you come to the thread give a reason why you dont like. and to be honest i like the bottom because its better than grey. i guess forgers dont realize that grey is boring and people playing the game want more than that. i get u dont have too much to work with but there is an enviorment. u can use that to make it look better.

[Imp3nded]

The map is fine. Stop.

[RagingChickens]

Like I said before, I do enjoy the map, and I do like the new concept of the rock jump to red and blue flag. It does have its flaws, (Bubble is really weird, the jump is retarded) but I don't think it deserves a full out bashing. I don't know anything about forging though, that is just how I see it.

[wcdd7]

The scale's off, and it's sloppy. Nuff said. The request for another midship confirms that this will be gone shortly.

[N!TRO]

I didn't really like it. The only thing that interested me was the ground lol... it was pretty bad imo. But hey lets see what some forgers can come up with.

[KRILLIN]

Just played it and liked it. Fun stuff!

[TechSlayer]

yeah sure. i played it last night with justin,, hooligan, maszik, plastic, gweedo, gym, and impended. first real fun game of reach in a while.

ahhh dude low blow, I was there too, even longer than gym.(I'm gonna go cry.) But yeah I thought the map consisted of good gameplay but it isn't too visually appealing.

[PK Toolboxxx]

ahhh dude low blow, I was there too, even longer than gym.(I'm gonna go cry.) But yeah I thought the map consisted of good gameplay but it isn't too visually appealing.

i knew i was forgetting someone lol. sry bro i dont mean to troll anyone lol.

[Gweedo888]

ha ha ha tech is cool also i think the only issue i seem to have with that map is lag. every time i play it there is a good amount of lag in it last night with forefront, pplastic,krillin and LONNIE lol there was a crap load of lag

[Inexist]

Feels like I am ice scating.

[Havoc]

Honestly thought the map was garbage...I couldn't believe KillerKC made it. I mean...water? Sand? Big rocks in the middle? And it's really not smooth which is what the midship maps all have in common. Not to bash, but I do not want to play that map ever again.