a list of all the maps they are testing for V3

[Its_genetics]

hello, im holding another lan tonight starting at six, So why am I ask you for help? well I need a list of the best maps from v3 that they are testing as well as the gametypes they work with. It would be much help to me if you all could give us some feedback.

[Inexist]

Killa KC's file-share? Maybe -_-

[Vox]

Killa KC's share (http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/FileShare.aspx?player=Killa%20KC)
but while you're at it...the guy who made Onslaught for Halo3 is working on a remake...
Onslaught (http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/FileShare.aspx?player=TLN%20SaLoT)
Test that out too...cause it's awesome

[SecretSchnitzel]

KillaKC and Ponytar's fileshares... Essentially a massive example of fail. :/
They've held three submission contests and have completely ignored the entirety of maps submitted from rounds 2 and 3. Suspended arena map in the likes of Guardian/Lockout without being a remake? Nada. Elongated map in the likes of Narrows? Nada. Two base symmetrical maps? All the way!
And now they're holding a 4th and 5th round. Round 4, a "low-budget" submission. Essentially the same maps they've failed to even look at before, and some already on their file shares, getting reforged with lower budgets... And a Midship remake request.
Absolute fail on MLG's part. From Pro's making a fuss and not giving maps a chance to KC making poor setting and map decisions, nothing but disappointment.

[Vox]

KillaKC and Ponytar's fileshares... Essentially a massive example of fail. :/
They've held three submission contests and have completely ignored the entirety of maps submitted from rounds 2 and 3. Suspended arena map in the likes of Guardian/Lockout without being a remake? Nada. Elongated map in the likes of Narrows? Nada. Two base symmetrical maps? All the way!
And now they're holding a 4th and 5th round. Round 4, a "low-budget" submission. Essentially the same maps they've failed to even look at before, and some already on their file shares, getting reforged with lower budgets... And a Midship remake request.
Absolute fail on MLG's part. From Pro's making a fuss and not giving maps a chance to KC making poor setting and map decisions, nothing but disappointment.

The fact that this is so true makes me sad...when the pros question why some of the good maps aren't even being tested you know something is wrong...

[SecretSchnitzel]

The fact that this is so true makes me sad...when the pros question why some of the good maps aren't even being tested you know something is wrong...

Considering that there are maps out there the Pros do like, and their disapproval of the current selection, there is something very wrong. There are a good number of maps that have had positive feed back from Pro's so far. Just about any of Mac Xl's remakes have recieved a lot of praise from them (for obvious reasoning), some of SaloT's work (particularly his new Onslaught remake), as well as my map Select and a handful of other forgers.
Its absurd that so much is simply being tossed aside without a second thought for some b/s back door politics and order of seniority amongst the forge community there.

[PK Toolboxxx]

i really dont understand y there cant be some communication between the pros and the testers. its just rediculous that they can figure it out.

OT: try affinity and prophet and onslot. they are sick.

[SecretSchnitzel]

i really dont understand y there cant be some communication between the pros and the testers. its just rediculous that they can figure it out.

OT: try affinity and prophet and onslot. they are sick.

Affinity is a good map. It was shooed into the V3 choices before it was even a published map though. In fact, it was Affinity that pretty much made the third submission period non-existent. Sure they took Nexus from that group, but Nexus is not an elongated map...
Prophet and Onslaught are both probably going to be ignored. Prophet because of more back door dealings and seniority b/s most likely. Onslaught simply because of KC. Both are amazing choices though.

[Justin21]

Rumor has it that prophet is really liked by most pros and could be included